After several weeks of working on a variety of unrelated projects (and several trips to actually wargame with other human beings) I am back to working on my prime project.
I have wargamed Inverlochy several times (two of which are documented in this blog) but I wanted to rework the board a bit for scenario writing. It is not greatly changed from my recent experiments using For King & Parliament but I had used a more stylized terrain and it was not properly scaled to a 9 x 12 grid.
As with every other battle that I have scaled, I use as the base the current Ordinance Survey (OS) maps. The 18th c. Roy Military Maps of Scotland are always interesting to look at but often don’t give the precise detail needed for scaling. In the case of Inverlochy, however, they show the ground before the railroad arrived (which caused a significant cut near and through the hill labeled above as Torn Na Farie. It shows the hill relative to the castle and probably gives a more accurate battlefield than my previous endeavors.
Using the Roy map overlaid to the OS I made a few slight changes to the terrain layout:
1. The hill is now closer to the castle. I had a comment passed on from a resident of the area which mentioned that it was his understanding that the Covenanter right flank was anchored on the hill. This adjustment would now more or less agree with that comment.
2. The castle is now correctly placed on a slight rise with the rise continuing to the east as shown in the Roy map.
3. The Roy map also indicates a small burn flowing south from the general area in which the Royalists formed up and on into the River Nevis. It is unnamed and it’s presence is not mentioned in any accounts, but I have added it for interest and given it, quite arbitrarily, a local name.
Argyll’s regiment, as such, may not have been a fully organized presence but likely they are the “pryme men” mentioned by Ruthven and are all or part of the veterans of this regiment. My reading of the sources suggest they were the second line behind the levies and not the first as many suggest. The Covenanter camp along the baseline will be treated as rough ground.
Some notes on building the scenario.
1) While Inverlochy is still a battle of the Scottish Civil War with Royalist and Covenanter sides properly demarcated, its primary dynamic is the ongoing struggle between Clan Donald and Clan Campbell. In fact in the heroic Celtic poetry Montrose is hardly mentioned (if at all). The extended rules for Highlanders (particularly pursuit) will likely need to be in full force to capture the flavor of the moment.
2) Some consideration needs to be given to the condition of the Royalist army. They had forced marched through difficult winter terrain and had arrived during both tired and hungry during the late evening of the previous day. They wanted the battle to begin and end quickly. At this writing I have placed the Royalist reserve to the east of the small burn which will cause a very slight road bump in activating them to move forward. Possibly placing the entire Royalist army to the east of the burn will end up being sufficient penalty.
3) Montrose had achieved strategic surprise but the sporadic skirmishing throughout the night had blunted the tactical surprise. The Covenanters are pinned in by water on three sides and the castle does not offer much of a refuge. Likely a generous apportionment of “untried” markers will be useful to capture their likely state of mind.
4) This is a very straight forward battle with little subtlety or maneuver. Probably it’s most interesting feature is its Highland character and the unabashed enmity between the sides. I will probably set break points for both sides at around 50%.